April 1st, 2009

Buffy - red and terrible and red

Is it in-character...

Some interesting comments in reaction to my Spuffy reunion in Thought You Should Know made me wonder what others thought about this:

Is it in-character for Buffy to punch a souled Spike upon learning that he's kept his return a secret post-Chosen? It's become a popular trope in fanfiction for Buffy to pop Spike in the nose for any Spuffy reunion, but is this something Buffy would do or does it show a devolution in their relationship?

Please explain your answer in the comments, if you can. :)


Is it in-character for Buffy to punch a souled Spike because she's angry?

Yes.
36(52.9%)
No.
16(23.5%)
Not sure.
10(14.7%)
Other. Will explain in comments.
6(8.8%)

Is it in-character for Buffy to punch any other souled characters (that she has a deep attachment to) if she's angry and they've personally wronged her?

Yes.
25(36.8%)
No.
29(42.6%)
Not sure.
5(7.4%)
Other. Will explain in comments.
9(13.2%)